(This is a corrected message.  Erase the last one.)
Buzzer problem solved.  The competitiveness is strictly between 1 and 2.
There is one large critical cycle.

The randomized competitiveness against an oblivious adversary is strictly
larger than 1 and strictly smaller than the deterministic competitiveness.
Every single one of the 34 nodes (not counting bizarre nodes) in the
red-black graph is critical in computing the randomized competitiveness,
but there are a few edges that are not critical.  (As I recall, only 10
of the edges, 8 red and 2 black, are not critical.)  We say that an edge
or node is critical in this sense if removing it would actually change the
competitiveness.
